This was the 38th annual Smokey Hill River Festival where there are separate fine art and craft shows associated with a music festival. This was the first year I participated in the Craft Show at this event in Salina, KS. Salina impressed me as a typical Midwest city complete with “small liberal arts college”, tree lined streets and lots of early 20th  century houses.

The event has the reputation of being one of the best of Midwest art/craft shows with attendance in excess of 70,000 and $500,000 in sales.

 

COSTS/AWARDS

Fine Art Show: Jury/Booth: $30/$275

Awards: 1 - $1500 purchase; 10 cash $500-$1500

Patronage: art patrons pledge to spend $135,000 in the Fine Art Show

 

Craft Show: Jury/Booth: $30/$325

Awards: 5 cash $300-$500

Patronage: $0.00

You can chew on this for what it is worth. My wife described the Fine Art Show as “edgy”.  I saw it as sort of “Cherry Creekish” with higher price point work than that of the Craft Show.

 

SET UP/TAKE DOWN

Set up was easy with a hoard of orange-shirt school kids.  I was a bit puzzled by Security at Mulberry St. Bridge allowing music goers into the park at 4:30pm but not allowing artists to enter and park for unloading until 5:00pm.  Some artists were allowed in earlier as they were parked and ready to unload, but this was not a problem for us. Set up was advertised as 5-8:00pm but we were allowed to work as late as 9:30-10:00pm. Setup was on grass in a park with large oak and other trees not familiar to me.  The 54 craft booths were arranged in four U-shaped areas and all had three sides of exposure.  The rule here is to unload and park elsewhere.  The farthest anyone would have to dolly to booth site was about 100’. Parking was available within the park, and in a lot less than a block from the park.

Take down was equally easy with the hoard of orange shirts appearing again to heft and tote. 

       

AMENITIES

As listed by the show:

  • Artists' Reception/Dinner, Friday evening;
  • Artists' Breakfast, Sunday morning
  • Set-up/tear-down assistance
  • Booth ambassadors
  • Refreshments provided at booth throughout the day
  • Free reserved parking close to show
  • Great booth layout (presentation from three sides)
  • Art Gift Certificate Program
  • Children's Art Purchase Program (priceless!)
  • Exceptional show committee and organization
  • On-site weather tracking
  • 24-hour security

In addition, there was a free muffin Friday morning, and snack bags with orange, apple and peanut-butter crackers on Friday and Saturday mornings.  The constant “Aquarians” delivered coffee and water in the morning, and iced tea and water in the afternoon.   You could not expect to have been treated better by a show.  Restrooms were port-a-pots with hand washing stations.

SALES/THE CROWD

     The crowd on Friday was mainly retirees, moms with daughters and infants, and the unemployed (?). We did a little over $600. Saturday there was a better mix in the crowd and we did a little over $1200. Sunday was slow (a little less than $800) but sales were mainly $100-$200 belts, gun leathers and canteens.  Overall I had 44 sales with the average being $68.  I missed my minimum ($3,000) for returning to the show by $2.00.

 

WEATHER

     Friday was a nice warm day but with a breeze.  Saturday there were sustained 20-30 mph winds with gusts to 40 mph.  Everyone survived but there were some anxious moments. Sunday was hot in the 90’s and HUMID!  Saturday, a front of violent thunderstorms swept across Kansas. Baseball-size hail was reported to the west and there was a tornado in Stockton (we saw the damage on the way home). Golf ball-size hail was reported north of Salina. I was up at 1:00am watching radar and weather reports. Salina dodged the bullet but got heavy wind-driven rain in between stronger cells to the north and south. I did not see any major damage at the show Sunday morning. I lost one of my books to water damage but everything else survived. I autographed the book and gave it to a young boy who has horses.

    

SUMMARY

     I applied to this show in 2013, was wait listed, then invited but I had already booked another show at that time. I wanted to do it to test how far east I might go with my leather work which is marketed to the western lifestyle/active outdoorsman market. I sold fewer belts but more holsters than normal.  Other artists who had done the show encouraged me to apply. My new motto is “Thou shalt not go farther east than 104W longitude old man”.

     We had fun in the area including brunch and visiting a gallery in Lindsborg (Little Sweden) and the famous Cozy Inn, in Salina. We also visited the bridge and hill from the movie Picnic filmed in Salina. I took time off from the booth to listen to a live zydeco band and really enjoyed watching the percussionist (“back porch music”). I got disoriented in Salina because of the lack of hills for landmarks. On the way home taking the “scenic route” rather than I 70, I knew we were headed the wrong way by the cattle with their butts turned toward the strong south winds.    

     I do not plan to return to this show because it did not meet my financial expectation and barely my minimum. It is simply outside my market and I do not want to travel a boring 8 hours across Kansas to develop a market there.  The other factor is the Midwest weather. I can handle the violent mountain weather in the afternoons in Colorado, but these storms that hit at night scare the crap out of me.  Give me the narrow mountain roads, lightning, crashing thunder, rain and hail any afternoon.

     Other artists told me this had been their “best show in 2013”, “slow”, “OK”, “pretty good”, “slower than last year”.  A willow furniture guy sold a complete set and a metal sculpture fellow made several sales of large yard art.  In the fine art section I did not see familiar wildlife and mountain scenery 2D art, and only a couple of “red rock” photographs. If your art fits a Midwest lifestyle, give this one a shot.  You will be treated very well.  

See also: www.artshowreviews.com for nuts and bolts of show. 

You need to be a member of Art Fair Insiders to add comments!

Join Art Fair Insiders

Votes: 0
Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • A lot of shows ask for art donations, and then the artworks are either sold or auctioned to help a charity cause. When we did the fine art show part of Smoky Hill in 2012, artists were asked to make an artwork donation (not required, but just asked) which would then be used to sell to children under a certain age. I've seen this type of situation at other shows as well and have even participated once or twice, but the Salina group only wants to offer the art to the kids for a price of $5 or less. I just didn't understand that aspect of the show at all. $5 isn't realistic for anything anymore no matter what a person's age. People spend that on a fancy latte daily. I don't think that a $5 per piece art show helps cultivate future art buyers, either.

    Did they ask for a donation for this purpose again? If so, what was the price artists set on their art?

    • Yes, it was $5 price. Good argument but can see both sides of the coin on this one. Kids of patrons could afford to pay more. For local lawn mowers in might be a good piece of change.
  • What a great review, Richard. I know first hand that Karla and her crew are the committee to judge others by. They are TOPS. We were in the 2012 show fine art section and luckily under a tree, but it was way too hot and couldn't have been any more humid. But our sales weren't as good as yours despite our winning Best of Show ($1,500 cash award). So we figured our work was actually too edgy and certainly too expensive for their patrons. We did make a small original art sale because we did win the award (the patron said she supports the Best of Show winner). We just didn't have the confidence in the patrons or the weather to return. But the hot weather was the main reason we didn't go back.

    I've always loved Salina, Kansas. We frequently spend the night there on our way to and from Florida. When I was a vinyl record collector, I did plenty business with Acoustic Sounds which is the largest distributor of new vinyl in the USA. I toured their facility at Salina once when we were traveling through. They also sponsor a blues festival that I've never been to but would like to see sometime. Since selling my entire collection of 4,500 records, I probably never will get to that festival. We'll see. I just like Salina.

    And I like driving across Kansas, too. Sorry to hear you didn't like it. I seldom drive I-70. There are so many great roads in that state that show very interesting terrain. You'll  see stuff you didn't think existed in Kansas.

    • Thanks for adding to the post Barrie. Eastern Colorado and western Kansas are "the high plains" and they are flat, flat flat like the Texas panhandle. It gets a little bumpy east of Stockton and you begin to see some rocks in road cuts. The winter-wheat fields were spectacular in the high winds - mesmerizing to watch the sea of wheat. I'm a nut for big machines and I got to see a lot of those in implement dealer lots.
  • You were there and didn't come and say hi? Lol!!

    I agree with you on the show. I did it 2013 and it was my best show of 2013. The Fine Art part is Saturday and Sunday. Setup on Friday. Easy setup and take down. I had the same kid show up from last year the minute I got there. He did all the heavy lifting. That was fun. Last year, I did 2/3 of my business on Sunday. I had a better Saturday, this year, than last year. However, Sunday was a big dud. Last year I sold 5-6 big pieces, $500 and up. This year, all my sales were $200 and under. Consequently, I did about half of what I did last year. Nobody showed up on Sunday. The crowd was only 1/3 of what it was last year. I don't think it was 90 degrees. It was warm, but, not uncomfortable.

    The work in the Fine Art section was uneven. There was nothing edgy about it. There were some Cherry Creek quality artists and there were some that weren't good at all. I usually don't complain about the prize winners. However, if I was a juror, the clay person who won the clay prize would have gotten my lowest score. Too bad because, except for the prize winner, there were really great clay artists at this show. Other clay artists at this show privately said the same thing before I had a chance to see the prize winner. I guess, the good thing about it is that anyone has a chance to win an award at a show because the judges can pick who they want.

    I was going to write about an aspect of the show in another post, but, I thought since Richard started this post, I would just add it here. Artists, at least the ones at this show, have learned what to do in case of bad weather, high winds, and heavy rain. I was too nervous to go to sleep Saturday night so I observed the tents in one of the worst conditions I have ever been in. Usually 30 mph winds are the high barrier before booths start to go over. On Saturday, all day, the gusts were up towards 40 mph. On Saturday night, the gusts reached 50 mph during an extremely heavy downpour. No booths blew over, no work got ruined, as far as I know, even the E-Z ups that were adequately staked and weighted didn't go over. That really impressed me.

    • Barry, sorry didn't know you were there or I would have run over. Thanks for adding to the post. I swear I drank close to three gallons of water Sunday, filling up every 25-20 minutes they came around LOL. Glad to be back up at 7000' in the cool mountain air and no humidity.
This reply was deleted.