Need some help on judging a competition

I'm the site administrator on an art web site, www.artsig.com , which is a critique site. We have a small competition going that just closed out, where the theme was a coffee or tea cup rendered in any media and any style. There were 19 entries, which are located at http://www.artsig.com/go/journals/read?id=117&forward=myjournalentries. If anyone would be interested in taking a look and choosing the three top works, it would be greatly appreciated. The works range from trying very hard to very impressive. Any comments left would also be appreciated.

In order to log in and leave comments or just a ranking of 1,2, and 3,  log in at the home page with "guest" as the user name and "guest" as the password. In order to cut down on any confusion, just sign the ratings or comments with either initials or a first name.  It would be easiest to copy the journal address and click on the home address, log in, and then paste in the journal address to get to the images. Just drop to the bottom of the post for the reply button.

 

I decided to not pick the winners myself as I don't want to seem like I have any partiality.

Votes: 0
E-mail me when people leave their comments –

You need to be a member of Art Fair Insiders to add comments!

Join Art Fair Insiders

Comments

  • Nancy, thanks :-)
  • i h had trouble leaving my votes which are 9,14 and 17--9 is hands down winner--it is universal and funny and a great picture

    please put this in for me

  • I don't know what happened. The site occasionally has glitches, but that's a new one on me. Thanks  for helping out, I 'll use what you left here. One of our AFI members here joined up and posted a work on there and has a few critiques left on her work. The site has a cross spectrum of accomplished artists and beginners. The site was without an active moderator for a couple of years, except the main administrator from the Photography sister site. I was asked to step in two years ago and it has been an uphill struggle to rejuvenate the site, but we're seeing some good results although we're short on painters.
  • Hey Robert, I went to the site and I tried to vote.  Once I left my choices (#2, #3, & #5) the little hour glass began turning and wouldn't quit.  I finally had to leave the site because it wasn't leaving the comment. 

    Jacki B

This reply was deleted.